Skip to content

Taffy

Legend has it that Salt Water Taffy was invented in 1883 by an Atlantic City candy shop owner whose boardwalk store flooded with salt water after a big storm. When a customer walked into the store and asked for taffy, the shopkeep sarcastically referred to it as “salt water taffy.” The name caught on and, ever since then, salt water taffy has been sold on the New Jersey Boardwalk and around the globe. Fun fact: Salt Water Taffy doesn’t actually contain any salt water.
  • Watermelon Taffy
    Watermelon Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Watermelon Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    Only 3 left!

    🍉 This soft and chewy taffy is bursting with watermelon flavor for an irresistible treat! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift messa...

    View full details
  • Banana Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Banana Split Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    Only 2 left!

    🍌 This soft and chewy treat is bursting with banana flavor! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ❄️ Carefully packaged to a...

    View full details
  • Butter Rum Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Butterbeer Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    11 in stock

    🧙 Our in-house wizards dreamt up this soft and chewy treat that's bursting with butterbeer flavor! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE g...

    View full details
  • Buttered Popcorn Taffy
    Buttered Popcorn Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Movie Popcorn Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    11 in stock

    🍿 Tired of picking kernels from your teeth? This soft and chewy taffy tastes remarkably like the real thing. It's one of our favorites! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 ...

    View full details
  • Peach Taffy
    Peach Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Peach Pie Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    Only 5 left!

    🍑 🥧 This soft and chewy treat is bursting with sweet peach flavor! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ❄️ Carefully packag...

    View full details
  • Huckleberry Taffy
    Huckleberry Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Huckleberry Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    Only 8 left!

    This soft and chewy taffy is bursting with huckleberry flavor for an irresistible treat! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift messag...

    View full details
  • Orange Taffy
    Orange Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Orange Juice Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    18 in stock

    🍊 This soft and chewy taffy is bursting with orange flavor for an irresistible treat! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ...

    View full details
  • Cherry Taffy
    Cherry Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Cherry Pie Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    Only 4 left!

    🍒 🥧 This soft and chewy treat is bursting with sweet cherry flavor! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ❄️ Carefully packa...

    View full details
  • Maple Taffy
    Maple Taffy
    Save $15.00

    French Toast Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    16 in stock

    🍁 This soft and chewy treat is bursting with sweet maple flavor! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ❄️ Carefully packaged...

    View full details
  • Caramel Apple Taffy
    Caramel Apple Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Caramel Apple Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    Only 4 left!

    🍏 This soft and chewy treat tastes just like a caramel apple! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ❄️ Carefully packaged to...

    View full details
  • Piña Colada Taffy
    Piña Colada Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Piña Colada Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    12 in stock

    🍹 This soft and chewy treat is bursting with sweet piña colada flavor! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ❄️ Carefully pa...

    View full details
  • Strawberry Taffy
    Strawberry Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Strawberry Jam Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    15 in stock

    This soft and chewy treat is bursting with strawberry flavor! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ❄️ Carefully packaged to...

    View full details
  • Raspberry Taffy
    Raspberry Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Raspberry Jam Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    15 in stock

    This soft and chewy treat is bursting with raspberry flavor! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ❄️ Carefully packaged to ...

    View full details
  • Lime Taffy
    Lime Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Key Lime Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    Only 10 left!

    This soft and chewy treat is bursting with citrusy lime flavor! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ❄️ Carefully packaged ...

    View full details
  • Wintergreen Taffy
    Wintergreen Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Fresh Mint Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    13 in stock

    🌿 This soft and chewy treat is bursting with refreshing wintergreen flavor! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ❄️ Careful...

    View full details
  • Apple Taffy
    Save $15.00

    S'mores Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    Only 3 left!

    🔥 Sit around the campfire and enjoy this soft and chewy treat that's bursting with toasted marshmallow, chocolate and graham cracker flavor! (1 lb...

    View full details
  • Irish Cream Taffy
    Irish Cream Taffy
    Save $15.00

    Lucky Irish Taffy

    Original Price $19.95
    Current Price $4.95
    13 in stock

    ☘️ This soft and chewy treat is bursting with sweet Irish cream flavor! (1 lb) 🇺🇸 Made In The U.S.A. 🎁 Include a FREE gift message! ❄️ Carefully p...

    View full details